Dessert prices in New Paltz, NY

Name: Dessert prices in New Paltz, NY
Creator: Tab Tender
License: https://tabtender.app/terms

A dessert in New Paltz typically costs $8.22 on the menu. Most places we track list desserts between $7.90 and $9.00 on average. Menus read September 2026.

Venue by venue, cheapest first

Average menu price of desserts at each venue we track in New Paltz, cheapest first
Venue	Average	Range
Pickled Pig DeliBreakfast · Restaurant	$3.76	$2.69 to $6.59
La CharlaMexican · Restaurant	$7.90	$6.50 to $9.00
McGillicuddy'sRestaurant	$8.22	$3.00 to $9.00
AgaveMexican · Restaurant	$9.00	$9.00
Gourmet PizzaPizza · Restaurant	$22.68	$2.00 to $45.00

Each venue's average listed price for desserts, from its own menu, with its cheapest and dearest. List prices, not what anyone paid; happy-hour prices are left out of every figure here.

More in New Paltz

Entrée prices Restaurants Everything in New Paltz

Figures for New Paltz come from itemized receipts split on Tab Tender, trimmed of outliers and weighted towards recent visits, and from venue menus, shown separately. How these numbers are built.