Skip to content
Tab Tender
Sign inCreate account

McGillicuddy's Menu Prices

VerifiedRestaurantNew Paltz, NY

On the menu

$16.75
Beer
$29.73
Entrée
$8.00
Wine

Average listed price, menu read September 2026. What people actually pay can differ.

Happy hour

HAPPY HOUR MENU: Glass of Wine $6 Well Drinks $4 Bud Light Drafts $3

Beer

normally about $16.75
  • Bud Light Drafts$3.00

Wine

normally about $8.00
  • Glass of Wine$6.00

Cocktail

normally about $14.50
  • Well Drinks$4.00

Side

normally about $20.23
  • Sides$8.95

Also on offer

  • Happy Beverages$3.00
  • Sweet Potato Fry (2.00)$7.95

As listed on their own menu, September 2026. Offers change without notice, so check before you go. These prices are deliberately left out of the averages above: a happy-hour price is not what the venue normally charges.

What things cost at McGillicuddy's

Beer$7.00 to $25.00$16.75
Wine$8.00
Coffee & tea$3.75
Soda$3.75 to $5.00$4.17
Juice$3.75
Appetizer$5.00 to $40.00$13.25
Entrée$1.00 to $80.00$29.73
Side$3.95 to $50.00$18.88
Dessert$3.00 to $9.00$8.22

Average price per category as listed on the menu, with the range from cheapest to priciest.

Menu from the venue's website, September 2026. Menu out of date?

Menu prices at McGillicuddy's

151 priced items. Prices change, so treat this as what was listed when we last checked.

Visiting McGillicuddy's

Loading map…
Address
84 Main Street, New Paltz, NY
Phone
+1-845-256-9289
Website
cuddysny.com

Common questions

Does McGillicuddy's have a happy hour?

Yes: beer $3.00, wine $6.00, cocktail $4.00, side $8.95. That is as McGillicuddy's lists it on their own site; offers change without notice, so check before you go.

How much is a beer at McGillicuddy's?

A beer on the menu at McGillicuddy's is about $16.75 (from $7.00 to $25.00).

How much is an entrée at McGillicuddy's?

An entrée on the menu at McGillicuddy's is about $29.73 (from $1.00 to $80.00).

More venues we track in New Paltz

AgaveGourmet PizzaPickled Pig DeliTokyo Sushi

How we compute this

Menu prices are the prices listed on McGillicuddy's's menu, averaged per category after dropping add-ons, market-price items and large formats like pitchers and bottles. They are list prices, not what anyone paid. Menus change; check with the venue before you go.

Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Been to McGillicuddy's? Scan your receipt and see what you really paid.

Split a bill, free

Scan the receipt, tap who had what, share pay links. No app, no sign-up to start.