Olde City Menu Prices
On the menu
- $18.75
- Entrée
- $14.50
- Wine
- $16.57
- Appetizer
Average listed price, menu read September 2026. What people actually pay can differ.
Happy hour
Classic Cocktails $12 | $10 During Happy Hour
Beer
- Draft Beer$6.00
- Yuengling Rings$13.00$9.00
Wine
normally about $14.50- Natural Wines$10.00
Cocktail
- Classic Cocktails$10.00
Hard seltzer
- Surfsides$9.00
Appetizer
normally about $16.57- Garlic Battered Cheddar Bites$14.00$9.00
Side
normally about $15.40- Real Deal Philly Pretzel$3.00$2.00
- Fries$7.00
Also on offer
- During happy hour$10.00
As listed on their own menu, September 2026. Offers change without notice, so check before you go. These prices are deliberately left out of the averages above: a happy-hour price is not what the venue normally charges. Cheapest is measured against the 27 happy hours we track in New York, not against every bar in it (see them all).
Olde City is a pub bar in New York, NY. It is known for serving classic pub fare like cheesesteaks and tenders, alongside a selection of popular beers.
What things cost at Olde City
Average price per category as listed on the menu, with the range from cheapest to priciest.
Menu from the venue's website, September 2026. Menu out of date? Something wrong?
Menu prices at Olde City
29 priced items. Prices change, so treat this as what was listed when we last checked.
Visiting Olde City
- Address
- 66 Madison Ave, New York, NY
- Hours
- Mon–Sun 11am–midnightFrom OpenStreetMap contributors, September 2026. Check before you go.
- Phone
- +1 929-281-3222
- Website
- loveoldecity.com
- Price range
- $$as the venue lists it
Common questions
Does Olde City have a happy hour?
Yes: beer from $6.00, wine $10.00, cocktail $10.00, hard seltzer $9.00, appetizer $9.00, side from $2.00. That is as Olde City lists it on their own site; offers change without notice, so check before you go.
How much is an entrée at Olde City?
An entrée on the menu at Olde City is about $18.75 (from $12.00 to $25.00).
More venues we track in New York
How we compute this
Menu prices are the prices listed on Olde City's menu, averaged per category after dropping add-ons, market-price items and large formats like pitchers and bottles. They are list prices, not what anyone paid. Menus change; check with the venue before you go.
Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Been to Olde City? Scan your receipt and see what you really paid.
Split a bill, freeScan the receipt, tap who had what, share pay links. No app, no sign-up to start.