Cantina Mexicana Menu Prices

VerifiedMexican · RestaurantStaten Island New York, NY

Mon–Thu 11:30am–10pm · Fri–Sat 11:30am–11pm · Sun 11:15am–7pm

On the menu

Entrée: $16.24
Appetizer: $11.85

Average listed price, menu read October 2026. What people actually pay can differ.

What things cost at Cantina Mexicana

Appetizer$5.00 to $18.00$11.85

Entrée$5.00 to $45.00$16.24

Average price per category as listed on the menu, with the range from cheapest to priciest.

Menu from the venue's website, October 2026. Menu out of date? Something wrong?

Menu prices at Cantina Mexicana

56 priced items. Prices change, so treat this as what was listed when we last checked.

Barbacoa Taco$5.00
Burger Taco$5.00
Campestre Chicken$5.00
Carnitas Taco$5.00
Piña Al Pastor$5.00 to $15.00
Veggie Taco$5.00
Birria Taco$7.00
Cancun Shrimp Taco$7.00
Toro Steak Taco$7.00
Alfonso's Taco$9.00
Cantina Cheese$9.00
Rib Eye Taco$9.00
Burrito Classico$10.00
House Salad$10.00
Cantina Salad$12.00
Pulled Chicken, Carnitas, Barbacoa, Veggies$14.00
Borracho BBQ$15.00
Diablo Rojo$15.00
BBQ Pork$16.00
Mariachi Mole$16.00
Puebla Fuego$16.00
Shrimp, Steak$16.00
Texas Cowboy$17.00
Acapulco Palmera$18.00
Grilled la Huerta$18.00
Toro Norteño$18.00
Rojas$21.00
Suizas$21.00
Burrito Loco$22.00
Pollo Al Chipotle$22.00
Birria Quesadilla$24.00
Grilled Chicken$24.00
Grilled Vegetables$24.00
Mole$25.00
Grilled Shrimp$28.00
Grilled Steak$28.00
Camarones a la Plancha$29.00
Salmon Al Chipotle$29.00
Churrasco Asado$36.00
Trio Fajita$38.00
Parrillada Cantina$45.00

See the full cost of a night out in Staten Island

Visiting Cantina Mexicana

Loading map…

Address: 140 New Dorp Lane, Staten Island, NY
Hours: Mon–Thu 11:30am–10pmFri–Sat 11:30am–11pmSun 11:15am–7pmAs listed on their site, October 2026. Check before you go.
Phone: +1 718-351-5474
Website: cantinamexicanasi.com

Nearby

Domenico’s Famous Ristorante & Cafe · 1.3 mi La Iguana Azul · 2.4 mi

Places like Cantina Mexicana nearby

Pizzaioli · Pizza · 2.7 mi Planet Wings · Restaurant · 2.7 mi Bagel Bistro · Restaurant · 2.7 mi Sing Bo Chinese & Pan Asian Bistro · Chinese · 2.8 mi

More venues we track in Staten Island

Capitaine Captain Dan's

How we compute this

Menu prices are the prices listed on Cantina Mexicana's menu, averaged per category after dropping add-ons, market-price items and large formats like pitchers and bottles. They are list prices, not what anyone paid. Menus change; check with the venue before you go.

Been to Cantina Mexicana? Scan your receipt and see what you really paid.

Split a bill, free

Scan the receipt, tap who had what, share pay links. No app, no sign-up to start.